ID the Future

Monday, June 4, 2007

Who brainwashed who? 2

Bullying or brainwashing…As mentioned in the previous post, we certainly wouldn’t want either to be a part of our unbiased scientific process would we.

Personally I would consider any purposeful deletion of information or manipulation of information that makes one’s
position seem more credible, a form of brain washing. Failing to include relevant information that would change conclusions would definitely be a form of brainwashing.

Let’s see…

When I was doing research about the previous post about bullying or brainwashing , I came across the page on Wikipedia that I footnoted concerning abiogenesis/ spontaneous generation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_generation

Since this issue of the origin of life is fundamental to the creation/ID vs. evolution debate I have researched it some in the past. As I read over the Wikipedia article about spontaneous generation I found a good bit of information being ignored in the article. Further study on Wikipedia did show the information was not unavailable, but it had to be dug up by someone serious about the subject. The casual reader who stops at one article would be totally “disinformned”.

First of all, they use the example of the famous Miller Urey experiment and leave you thinking that this experiment was truly groundbreaking and is today still considered to be. Let me add a few facts that have been left out, I hope inadvertently.

First, the value of the experiment itself is now in doubt, because many scientists feel Miller-Urey may have been mistaken about the basic composition of the atmosphere used. Miller-Urey assumed a reducing atmosphere (rich in ammonia), rather than an oxidixing (rich in free oxygen) atmosphere was necessary, and adjusted their experiment accordingly.

Here we find the first evidence of brainwashing. Miller and Urey knew that an OXYGEN rich atmosphere would eventually destroy their precursors to life. “Rust” is just one form of oxidixation. However to support the life that spontaneously generates, you MUST have oxygen…quite a fact to inadvertently leave out. I hope it was inadvertent.

The fact IS mentioned on the following Wiki post:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment#Earth.27s_early_atmosphere for anyone willing to search for more information.

I hope you noticed this sentence “In practice gas mixtures containing CO, CO2, N2, etc. give much the same products as those containing CH4 and NH3 so long as there is no O2.”

And this sentence further down in the section “when oxygen gas is added to this mixture, no organic molecules are formed.”

“As long as there is no O2”? “When oxygen gas is added…no organic molecules are formed.”

The major life sustaining gas in our environment had to be ABSENT for abiogenesis to occur?

Secondly, the products of the experiment were incompatible with the formation of life.

All amino acids have something called chirality. This is represented by a “D-“ or an “L-“. Although this is sometimes compared to a “right or left handedness”, due to the three dimensional structure of amino acids there is no actual “left” or “right”. Amino acids in the proteins of living organisms are L- amino acids. The opposite amino acid is often detrimental to life, (i.e. poisonous).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_isomerism#Chirality_in_biology

The products of the Miller-Ulay experiment, were approximately a 50-50 D- and L-mix.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment#Experiment_and_interpretation

As have been any other amino acids produced “spontaneously” by scientists working in laboratories.

Thirdly, for all the hubbub, only very miniscule amounts of the amino acids were generated. The idea of life spontaneously generating in a “pre-biotic soup”, requires a very dense concentration of these amino acids, as well as hundreds or thousands of other “materials”. The tiny percentage of amino acids created could never become a “dense soup” in a world engulfed in water. Of course this is the basis of the current “better” theory that this soup was created in a pond or lagoon allowing for the necessary concentrations. (reference same as above)

Fourthly, the acids formed were removed by Miller and Urey, because the electrical spark would have destroyed them! How close is that to a naturally occurring atmosphere? Who would have done this in the primitive earth? God? http://www.theunjustmedia.com/The%20molecular_impasse_of_evolution.htm

Another experiment listed in the abiogenesis article was by Joan Oró, a celebrated Spanish scientist. To quote the article “One of his most important contributions was the prebiotic synthesis of the nucleotide adenine (a key component of nucleic acids ) from hydrogen cyanide. This was achieved during the period 1959-1962 and stands, together with the Miller-Urey experiment, as one of the fundamental results of prebiotic chemistry.”

Hydrogen cyanide is described at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_cyanide as “...highly poisonous... commonly listed amongst chemical warfare agents…”. Am I the only person that finds it odd that the nucleotide, pre-cursor to an amino acid, was formed from hydrogen cyanide? How much life could be sustained in an atmosphere that is rich in hydrogen cyanide? How brainwashed do you have to be to have your hope of life without a Creator based on an atmosphere of poisonous gas?

I have one final criticism. Does it strike anyone other than me as odd that some of the best results in “prebiotic” chemistry are more than 4O years old? Shouldn’t we have gotten something more exciting than a miniscule amount of nucleotides created in a poisonous atmosphere or half poisonous amino acids produced in an environment not fit for life in the last 40+ years?

Mr. Dawkins, if these two experiments are the best evidence for life spontaneously generating without a Creator, I have to ask you, who is being bullied and brainwashed here?

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Sorry for the Lack of Postings

I want to apologize to any one who has been kind enough to stop by and visit this blog. As you can tell there have been no postings for quite some time...

For the last few months I have been trying to decide whether to continue with this blog or not. I know it might seem premature to be thinking about killing a blog that only began in December...
the fact that I have been extremely busy in a new phase of life and the comments of some people caused me to stop and reconsider the need for such a blog.

But now I have decided that I will continue this blog at the rate of once every 2 weeks. The subject matter can be difficult especially to translate for my Japanese language blog, but I have become aware of the definite need for such information.

I have heard several prominent (and not so prominent) Christians make comments about the "evidence for evolution" recently. That bothers me...

Although the issues addressed here are not "unto salvation", people must be told that so much of what is reported as fact on this issue is not. There are almost as many opinions as there are scientists and there is very little agreement on many of the issues promoted as fact. Most disturbing is the "disinformation" that occurs.

And so I will pick up my "pen" ( or keyboard as it were) again and push on.
True science is following the data where ever it may lead...and you might be pleasantly surprised...

Sunday, December 17, 2006

Mr.Dawkins, who brainwashed who?

Richard Dawkins made the following statement "It is absolutely safe to say that if you meet somebody who claims not to believe in evolution, that person is ignorant, stupid or insane(or wicked, but I'd rather not consider that)." in 1989 according to Free Inquiry magazine, Volume 21, Number 3.( actual link is http://www.secularhumanism.org/library/fi/dawkins_21_3.html)


To be honest, I was amazed every single time I had read the original quote. But after I read the whole article that was the follow up to that statement, I was even more amazed. Here is more from the same article: "I don't withdraw a word of my initial statement. But I do now think it may have been incomplete. There is perhaps a fifth category, which may belong under "insane" but which can be more sympathetically characterized by a word like tormented, bullied, or brainwashed. Sincere people who are not ignorant, not stupid, and not wicked can be cruelly torn, almost in two, between the massive evidence of science on the one hand, and their understanding of what their holy book tells them on the other."(Free Inquiry magazine, Volume 21, Number 3. ) (http://www.secularhumanism.org/library/fi/dawkins_21_3.html)

As always, Mr. Dawkins strives to come across as the proverbial "unbiased, unimpeded by preconceptions" scientist.

But I have to be very honest...I find that very hard to swallow. Or maybe I should say I am extremely tired of that misconception....

Until the time of Louis Pasteur(1822-1895), a lot of very "great scientific minds" believed in the idea of "spontaneous generation". Most you know this is the mistaken idea that rats would spontaneously appear from rags left on the floor, or maggots spontaneously appeared on meat.

Even the great philosopher Aristotle believed aphids formed from the dew on plants, fleas from putrid matter, mice from dirty hay. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spontaneous_generation

Most of you may also know that Pasteur preformed the experiment that proved, scientifically, once and for all that "spontaneous generation" was not correct. This is something that I learned in grade school, and I am almost certain that all of you reading learned also. Life only comes from life.

Life only comes from life...proved by Louis Pasteur in 1862...taught in grade school science as a basic rule of biology.

But then a few years later we learn the above is true, and Aristotle and all those people were wrong, EXCEPT in the case of ALL LIFE on our planet...the emergence of all life was, by accident, spontaneously generated "just this once", because there can't be any other explaination.

Doesn't any one besides me wonder, to use Mr. Dawkins own words, how "tormented, bullied, or brainwashed" you have to be to go against one of the basic laws of biology to explain the origin of all life on the planet!?!?!?!

Tormented, bullied, brainwashed...very strong emotionally charged words. I would have made sure they couldn't be used against me before I used them myself, Mr. Dawkins. (to be continued)



Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Of Moths and Revolutions

One of the most famous evidences for evolution used is the purported change in moths, supposedly, caused by the industrial revolution in England. As you may know, (some) scientists claim the number of dark colored moths increased as compared to light colored moths due to pollution on tree trunks.

There appears to be evidence now that the famous picture was staged. ("Icons of Evolution" by Jonathan Wells) Because in fact, the moths seldom, if ever, land directly on tree trunks. That anyone would stage pictures to "support" there theory, doesn't seem very scientific to me .

BUT to be honest, the information that the picture was staged is NOT what makes me reject this so called “evidence” for evolution.

Actually I rejected these famous moths when I was in university from 1981-1985. At the time I was neither a follower of Christ (I am now) nor a creationist, BUT I immediately rejected this as example of evolution. And here is why...

While this example does show a shift in the population ratio, it is ONLY a shift in the population ratio. There were light colored moths BEFORE the industrial revolution (IF, in fact, there was a ratio change). What the “scientists” did is “infer” that this "micro evolution", was evidence for "macro evolution".

Or in other words, they decided that this change in a predominance of light colored moths to a predominance of darker moths proves that amoebas gradually changed into human beings.

However, every class that I had that discussed genetics (several plant and animal science classes as part of my agriculture degree), we always were shown the “bell curve of genetic distribution”. This is a diagram that shows any population of farm animals or plants has a genetic potential of “variation” nearly equal either way from a central point. Anyone or group of characteristics has a certain amount of genetic variability, BUT then you hit an impenetrable barrier. The curve hits a “zero” point on both sides.

There is a limited amount of variation for every trait.

In other words, although there are larger and smaller breeds of cattle, you never get cattle as big as an elephant. Or to put it another way, you can try to increase the harvest by selective breeding, but there is ALWAYS a limit to the yield you will get.

HOW can daily, practical examples of limited genetic potential be correct when you are farming, one of the most down-to-earth occupations...pun intended, but incorrect when you are talking about the entire web of life on this planet?

The bell curve, that demonstrates the limitation to genetic change, is the reason that little white and black moths, glued to trees or not, never really gave any indication that we all came from singled celled bacteria. It just isn't in the genes.


Saturday, December 9, 2006

The Rest of The Story

Let's finish the quote I started before from Stephen Jay Gould's "The Panda's Thumb".


"The evolutionary trees
that adorn our textbooks have data only at the tips and nodes of their branches; the rest is inference, however reasonable, not the evidence of fossils....Darwin...wagered his entire theory on a denial of this literal record:

'The geological record is extremely imperfect and this fact will to a large extent explain why we do not find interminable varieties, connecting together all the extinct and existing forms of life by the finest graduated steps. He who rejects these views on the nature of the geological record will rightly reject my whole theory.'

Darwin's arguement still persists as the favored escape of most paleontologists from the embarrassent of a record that seems to show so little of evolution directly....I wish in no way to impugn...gradualism...I wish only to point out that it was never "seen" in the rocks."("The Panada's Thumb", Penguin Books, 1987 pg. 151; emphasis added)

This is almost unbelievable. Even though one of the biggest evidences we hear to support the theory of evolution is "the fossil record", BOTH Stephen Jay Gould AND Charles Darwin are saying evolution is NOT seen in the rocks. That should come as a surprise to quite a few people.

I suggest you get a copy of "The Panada's Thumb" and read it for yourself.

Monday, December 4, 2006

By Design

There are a few things in my life that I am very passionate about...one of those things is the debate about creation and evolution. As someone who has always been intrigued by science and especially biology, I read many articles from various sources concerning this issue. One of my favorite authors, even today, is the now deceased Stephen Jay Gould.(Yes, I do realize he was a very vocal anti-creationist.)

In my reading, especially of Gould, one of the most surprising things was to find out how little real evidence there is for the theory of evolution. Gould says, "The extreme rarity of transitional forms in the fossil record persists as the trade secret of paleontology. " ("The Panada's Thumb", Penguin Books, 1987 pg. 150; emphasis added). Amazingly, Gould himself also often wrote about how bias of scientists has affected many of the accepted, but later disproved scientific theories, in many different fields.

In this blog I will attempt to give both evidence AGAINST the theory of evolution and FOR creation and/or Intelligent Design. I pray that anyone who is truly opened minded will take the time to at least read and look into this subject for themselves. To accept ANY belief, without questioning or thinking for one's self, is not the answer in ANY situation...